The end of the school year felt like a battlefield, empty and scared by explosions. It was quiet, but panic, trauma, and violence hung in the air.
All of the year ending rituals were on Zoom. At their best, they were a shadow of they were replacing, and at the worst, they were a painful exercise of technology failing to meet expectations and the needs of our community.
Everything was hard when we went remote, and everything was overwhelming. Each week, each day had a new challenge. We were blessed with resources at our schools, but no amount of money could make up for the insecurity of doing things for the first time with students without adequate planning time.
Most teachers teach with a combination of tried and true lessons and new units in their curriculum. Last spring, so many of us had to develop new units because what we had done in the past didn't work. I teach the middle school concert band.
You can't do the middle school concert band over Zoom. So, the curriculum changed into small group lessons. I didn't know how to teach my 5th graders the music of the middle ages that they normally performed at the end of the year. Virtual choir is a lot harder and more expensive than it looks, and teaching almost sixty students how to sing a song over Zoom was a challenge I could not overcome.
I had a lot of new material in my curriculum and lesson that I taught before from years past; I had to teach differently in a way I never taught before. Everything was new, and teaching last spring felt like being a first-year teacher.
Teachers all across America were scrambling like I was because the schools were not ready to be remote. The transitions for most schools were sudden, rushed, and felt like a violent earthquake.
Guardians panicked and struggled with remote learning. I was privileged to be a remote teacher while my child was in remote learning. Many adults were not so lucky. Some were able to work remotely. Schools' critical role in childcare for millions of children in America was taken away to little to no notice. Some parents' solutions included compromising their quarantine while others had to quit jobs to make distance learning work. The vast majority of the people who quit jobs were women.
While I struggled with Google Classroom and Zooms, other teachers struggled with so much more. Some communities didn't have the privilege of access to fast internet. Teachers resorted to using WIFI from stores and churches sitting in their cars in parking lots.
Many schools did not have enough devices for students, so siblings had to share, and some families had to go without. This led to teachers delivering packets of materials door to door and teaching over phone landlines to make things work.
Many schools all across America weren't even focused on teaching when schools closed. They were trying to get food to children. 29.6 million children every day in America get free or reduced-price lunches from schools while 11.9 million get breakfast. For many children, this is the only meal they get that day. Administrators and teachers had no guidance or support from the federal government, and many only had little help from local governments. Communities came together in amazing ways to make sure food got to children. There were many bumps in the road to make this happen, but school came through in amazing ways during this tough time.
As we are struggling to make this work, people are dying at alarming rates. Stressed, scared, overworked, and exhausted teachers yearning for a message of empathy and needing financial support instead get a president urging schools to open up before the school year ends.
Even though it's an absurd idea, and it feels like a punch in the gut, a callous disregard for children and teachers' safety. In response, the battle lines are drawn, and teachers and parents fight to keep schools closed. Science and reasons prevail, and schools in America stayed closed for the end of the 2019-2020 school year, but the conflict is not over. As teachers close the school year and walk away from school year shell-shocked, not knowing how or when they would have to return to battle.
They take respite in the silence, many not realizing that there is something even more challenging up ahead.
This is what I wrote about the possibility of going back to in-person learning on 5/8/20 from this blog post.
Can American schools open in the fall with the current trends? No. The way that we think about schools, asking educator to make magic happen with limited resources, as opposed to asking them what they need to be successful and providing what they ask for is not setting us up for success in this crisis. By sheer force of will and hard work, a teacher can make an out of date history book work in a classroom, force of will cannot provide sanitation supplies and smaller class sizes.
In the past week there have been a flurry of articles talking about plans for opening schools next year. Most of them completely lack an understanding of child development. Having first graders sit six feet apart, not move from classroom from classroom, eat lunch at their desks, and have no recess is not developmentally appropriate. Is it worse than having students stay at home? For some children yes, for others no. This makes things complicated. And articles that respond to these concerns that state that children are “resilient,” should be immediately disregarded, as this pop psychology myth of childhood resilience is completely false and misguided.
If schools continue to have to make choices in the fall like they have this past spring with little financial support, meaningful leadership, and plans that are both educationally and psychologically sound, the only safe choice will be to start the year with distance learning that will last until at least until the new year.